On the day after Derrick Bird shot dead 12 people in Cumbria BBC Radio 4 broadcast a play entitled Six Impossible Things. Based on the true story of a murderer, it contained the line 'I'll put a bullet in your brain'. 66 complaints were made to the network, which quickly apologised and declared it had been wrong to broadcast the play. Why did this upset people? Who were they? Could they be protesting about anything more than ironic coincidence?
This seems part of the disturbing willingness to be part of a 'community of grief' which has marked British society since the death of Diana. People seem to need to think of themselves as 'victims' of tragic events, imagining that it's just too painful in their grief-stricken state to be confronted with images of any sort of violence. I vividly remember that a day or so after Diana's death the scheduled movie, Lethal Weapon III, was replaced by the sentimental (and wonderful) film, Field of Dreams, as if watching Mel Gibson's wild staring eyes as he brandished the eponymous firearm was just too upsetting for those in a fragile state after the tragedy. Of course this sentimentality is all media-led, as the duty of the news networks and newspapers is seemingly to create a community united in outrage and grief. The BBC is the prime offender here, so at least there is another irony: that its drama wing has to play by the strange rules it enforces elsewhere.
Friday, 11 June 2010
Tuesday, 1 June 2010
Because You Were Home: The Strangers
The Strangers is a film utterly without redemption - along the lines of ‘torture porn’ movies such as the Saw series and Wolf Creek. Having endured the motiveless terrorizing and torture of a couple who just happen to be ‘home’ when a group of random attackers choose to call, we are left with no hope, not even a deeper ‘point’. The opening of the film refers to some real event which ‘inspires’ the movie, though the makers appear to be unaware what this actually was or unwilling to reveal it. More likely, they don’t care.
The opening is genuinely scary, especially when the girl knocks at the door at 4 in the morning asking for ‘Tamar’ and, when told she’s not there, says plaintively ‘Are you sure?'. When we see one of the attackers suddenly inside the house, on the margins of the frame, while the central Liv Tyler character remains oblivious, it's absolutely terrifying. But from then on the movie has nowhere to go. It seems unsure and indifferent to what the point of all this is, other than – to go by the word of the director on the accompanying DVD Extras – to provide some innovative kind of movie horror experience. But this ambition extends beyond little other than technical innovations such as constructing the house in a vast studio so that the echoes are as loud and spooky as possible.
No, if there is a point it is simply that one’s home can be easily invaded. It thus reminds me of David Hare’s comment that the message underpinning Patricia Highsmith’s fiction is that ‘once you set your mind to it, any one human being can destroy any other’. In The Strangers, when asked by the Liv Tyler character why they do this, the masked intruders reply: ‘Because you were home’. This seems to refer to the victims just happening to be in while the killers were on their random spree. But it also conveys a deeper logic, that being ‘home’, counter to all the conventional connotations of safety and security, is where you are at your most vulnerable. This message is in keeping with the general paranoid tenor of 21st century America. But it's actually something that horror films have taught us more implicitly for decades. Think of the common post-horror-film experience of having your own house transformed suddenly into a location for potential evil as you eye dark spaces nervously and rush past empty rooms on the way to the safety of bed. It's the home that is made strange.
The opening is genuinely scary, especially when the girl knocks at the door at 4 in the morning asking for ‘Tamar’ and, when told she’s not there, says plaintively ‘Are you sure?'. When we see one of the attackers suddenly inside the house, on the margins of the frame, while the central Liv Tyler character remains oblivious, it's absolutely terrifying. But from then on the movie has nowhere to go. It seems unsure and indifferent to what the point of all this is, other than – to go by the word of the director on the accompanying DVD Extras – to provide some innovative kind of movie horror experience. But this ambition extends beyond little other than technical innovations such as constructing the house in a vast studio so that the echoes are as loud and spooky as possible.
No, if there is a point it is simply that one’s home can be easily invaded. It thus reminds me of David Hare’s comment that the message underpinning Patricia Highsmith’s fiction is that ‘once you set your mind to it, any one human being can destroy any other’. In The Strangers, when asked by the Liv Tyler character why they do this, the masked intruders reply: ‘Because you were home’. This seems to refer to the victims just happening to be in while the killers were on their random spree. But it also conveys a deeper logic, that being ‘home’, counter to all the conventional connotations of safety and security, is where you are at your most vulnerable. This message is in keeping with the general paranoid tenor of 21st century America. But it's actually something that horror films have taught us more implicitly for decades. Think of the common post-horror-film experience of having your own house transformed suddenly into a location for potential evil as you eye dark spaces nervously and rush past empty rooms on the way to the safety of bed. It's the home that is made strange.
Monday, 17 May 2010
Watching Cloverfield Again

Cloverfield is an object-lesson in how to revitalise an established genre. It's a monster movie, but the genre is presented from a different point of view, as if we are looking in from the outside. It is also the movie which reveals how 9/11 taught Hollywood how to do disaster. According to Slavoj Zizek, in his instant response to the catastrophe, 'The Desert of the Real', one of the striking things about the media coverage of 9/11 is how it showed that we had been 'prepared for' the event by movies depicting the destruction of US cities such as Escape From New York and Independence Day. But Cloverfield shows that there is a parallel knock-on effect. Want to know how people react in the face of a crisis? Replicate the real footage of people running in panic around the streets of New York. Need to detail the moment when it's suddenly clear nothing will ever be the same again? Replicate the home video inadvertently capturing the moment tragedy strikes. Equipping the cultural imagination (see also 2006's Right At Your Door) with the ability to depict disaster with supreme accuracy is one of the clear consequences of 9/11.
Sunday, 16 May 2010
Blitz Street

What an unsettling experience watching Channel 4's Blitz Street is. The programme has built 'a row of terraced houses specially built on a remote military base and subjected it to a frightening range of large-scale bombs and incendiaries similar to those dropped by the Luftwaffe' (Channel 4). Experts then proceed to analyse the damage done by each bomb - the SC50, the SC500 etc. This insight into the devastation wrought by the weaponry is accompanied by 'emotional eye witness testimonies, giving a fantastic insight into day-to-day life on the home front and the immense psychological damage caused by the bombardment'. But the effect on the human beings who had to live through this shattering of masonry, glass and wood remains implicit. As is clear from the excited expert analysis of the effects of the bombs, the programme-makers have invested all their energy into the reconstruction and destruction of the buildings. The result is a rather autistic attempt to comprehend the horrors of war - despite all the noise and violence, we are left with a 'clean' analysis, untroubled by mess, but missing the point. The unspoken element, of course, is the human body. What would bring together emotional testimony and destroyed buildings is a similarly forensic dissection of the smashing of human flesh and bones. Now that would be emotional.
Mr Benn's Secret Life

Coming back to Mr Benn after several decades was a surprise. I'd always thought of it as a programme about the magic of escapism. Each episode reveals the enrichment of one man's daily existence following his indulgence in his fantasy life. Watching it again, however, I couldn't help fixating on Mr Benn's normal life as depicted in each episode. This is a man who dresses up in a suit and bowler hat yet never goes to work, lives in a bustling street but has no friends, owns a three-bedroom terrace house but shares it with no one. The only person he speaks to in his real life is a shopkeeper. What a desolate figure! Rather than a childhood world of unlimited potential, Mr Benn is an emblem of the alienation of modern existence. His real secret-life lurks not in the fancy-dress shop but beneath that sober suit and tie. What has happened in his past? Has he lost his job, divorced, never been able to start a relationship? What will become of him? What will happen when he becomes increasingly addicted to his fantasy-life and starts carrying it into Festive Road, walking around dressed as a knight, explorer, astronaut, etc., frightening the children? The real tragedy here is that none of his neighbours would notice.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


