Monday, 5 August 2013

10 of the best private eye movies ever made


Entry for Reaktion Books blog (on 31st July 2013) to mark publication of The Private Eye: Detectives in the Movies by Bran Nicol.

Available at: http://www.amazon.co.uk/Private-Eye-Detectives-Locations-Reaktion/dp/1780231024/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1375706506&sr=1-1&keywords=Bran+Nicol+the+private+eye

Thanks to countless portrayals over the years, the private investigator is one of the most familiar characters in cinema. Think of Humphrey Bogart looking out quizzically from under his fedora in The Maltese Falcon and The Big Sleep, Jack Nicholson in Chinatown, ‘branded’ by having his nose unceremoniously sliced by a hood (played with relish by director Roman Polanski), or Mickey Rourke in Angel Heart, finally able to look himself in the mirror, and terrified by what he sees: ‘I know who I am!’

My book is the first study of this classic cinematic figure. It offers readers two things: first, a history of the private eye movie, containing discussions on the most significant examples from the 1940s to the early twenty-first century and, second, an analysis of what I think they are really about.

It’s natural to see the private eye as a heroic beacon of masculinity. But as I watched and re-watched scores of movies while researching the book, a different kind of figure emerged. The private eye is not really about steely heroism, or brilliant detection, or rooting out dangerous criminal elements from society. No, his job is more simply to present us with the mysteries of private life. The special function of the private eye is to enter into people’s private spaces and expose them to us, the viewers, so we reflect on our own.

Given the rise of new media, social networking and reality TV, the News of the World scandal, the Leveson Inquiry and the current furore about government surveillance, questions of privacy are more urgent and complex in the twenty-first century than ever, and this, despite the fact that it represents a bygone, very twentieth-century world, is one of the values of thinking about this movie tradition now.

Having the chance to immerse myself in some wonderful pieces of cinema was one of the great pleasures of writing the book. As a taster, here are examples of what I consider to be the ten best. As with all such lists, it probably reflects personal preference more than anything else, and no doubt will prompt disagreement. In particular, you might be surprised that half my choices are movies that pay homage to the great films noirs of the 1940s and ’50s rather than coming out of this period. However, besides finding these films more gripping and satisfying, I’d argue that since the 1970s directors seem to have managed to find ways in which to capitalize on the potential of private eye movie conventions to say something profound and poignant about human beings.

Angel Heart (1987)
Overblown and bombastic it may be, but Alan Parker’s Gothic take on the private eye movie is still compelling and frightening. Mickey Rourke – before his decline, and recent rebirth – is the perfect private investigator, a loner, rather dishevelled but plausibly attractive to woman, sassy and scared in equal measure, traversing a set of ‘mean streets’ new to the genre: those of New Orleans.
Memorable scene: a demonic Robert de Niro peels his hard-boiled egg with long sharpened fingernails before devouring it with conviction. Breakfast will never be the same again.

The Maltese Falcon (1941)
The first ‘proper’ private eye movie, and for many the first proper film noir. Humphrey Bogart’s Sam Spade is barely off-screen as he attempts to figure out a double mystery: who killed Floyd Thursby and Spade’s own partner Miles Archer, and where is the eponymous priceless artefact that so many criminals are trying to get hold of? The true mystery, though, is Spade himself, and what makes this curiously heroic, morally ambiguous figure tick.
Memorable scene: the famous ending, as Mary Astor’s femme fatale, Brigid O’Shaughnessy, is ushered into a lift to take her downstairs. Ostensibly this is so she can be dealt with by the law, but as the bars of the lift close on her and the dramatic music kicks in, it’s clear this is really a descent into hell.

Laura (1946)
Another film revealing the Gothic origins of the noir private eye thriller, this one revolves around a clash of worlds, as jobbing police detective Mark McPherson (Dana Andrews) investigates the apparent murder of the beautiful socialite and advertising executive Laura Hunt (Gene Tierney). Goaded by her ‘friend’, the effete novelist Waldo Lydecker, who finds him vulgar and ‘cheap’, McPherson loses his bearings as he tries to get to grips with the case. This is because he has fallen in love with the portrait of Laura hanging over her fireplace even before she suddenly reappears . . .
Memorable scene: McPherson has taken, rather strangely, to wandering around Laura’s empty apartment and, having helped himself to a whisky, falls asleep in an armchair under Laura’s portrait, only for him to be startled awake as she herself suddenly walks in. His fantasy about Laura seems so strong that it’s somehow managed to revivify the real person.

Kiss Me Deadly (1955)
Stylish and violent, this film sees the wandering ‘Chandlerian’ private eye recast as borderline psychopath. Ralph Meeker plays the sadistic, womanizing Mike Hammer with relish: street-smart, dapper, but with a undeniable streak of cruelty. The film is beautifully shot, showing just how far film noir in the 1950s has come since the previous decade’s B-movie origins. It also elevates the standard hard-boiled plot of Spillane’s original novel (married woman meets dangerously attractive drifter, trouble ensues) into a paranoid, apocalyptic Cold War drama revolving around, er, the ‘great whatsit’.
Memorable scene: trying to find an Italian opera singer’s apartment, Hammer walks cautiously, gun at the ready, around a shadowy LA apartment block (in a part of pre-renovation LA district Bunker Hill – now lost forever, apart from in films like this) made to seem like an eery labyrinth by the overhead camera.

Klute (1971)
Set in an inescapably claustrophobic New York, Klute marks a departure not just from the Chandlerian wandering private eye but from California, where the majority of 1970s private eye films are set. Nevertheless it revolves around a typical private-eye theme: the inability of the detective to remain detached from a case. John Klute (Donald Sutherland at his thoughtful, taciturn best) falls for Jane Fonda’s Brée Daniels, the high-class prostitute he is supposed to protect from a killer at large in the city. The innovative camera angles and creepy soundtrack manage to make the viewer fluctuate between feeling helpless and complicit in the stalker’s intrusions into Daniels’s life.
Memorable scene: all the terrible vulnerability of a woman alone in an uncaring metropolis is conveyed as Daniels settles down in her bed late at night, and the phone rings . . .

Brick (2005)
Rian Johnson’s cool, indie 'mash-up' of genres – high school movie meets film noir – manages to breathe new life into the private eye movie. It’s a reworking of The Maltese Falcon for the slacker generation, with the eponymous object a block of heroin rather than a jewel-encrusted ornament. The combination of genres invites us to think of the private eye in a new way: as an adolescent trying to enter the unforgiving adult world. He is morally pure, though often tempted by impurities, and tries to preserve justice in a world where official law is nowhere to be seen.
Memorable scene: Brendan Fraser’s desolation is palpable as the camera stays fixed, unflinchingly, as he crouches in a storm drain beside the abandoned body of his dead girlfriend.

Murder, My Sweet (1944)
No doubt it might seem a little heretical to choose this film over the more celebrated early Chandler adaptation starring Humphrey Bogart, The Big Sleep (1946). But Murder, My Sweet, the first time Philip Marlowe appears on screen (played by a believably vulnerable Dick Powell), is superior both in its plotting and its depiction of a detective entering a bewildering, dangerous world. This film combines the classic noir techniques of chiaroscuro lighting, subjective camera angles and flashback voice-over narration, to end up with the closest cinema has come to Chandler’s convoluted first-person novels.
Memorable scene: Marlowe begins and ends the movie with a bandage over his eyes in a shadowy interrogation room surrounded by police – a clear visual metaphor for the detective’s inability to see what has been in front of his eyes until the very end.

The Long Goodbye (1973)
A movie which, as one critic of the time noted, ‘satirizes Hollywood and the entire Chandler genre’. Nevertheless, as Elliott Gould’s downscaled Marlowe shambles around his neighbourhood, always one step behind, Altman’s brilliant movie captures the essence of the private eye better than any other. A lone hero, faced with a bewildering, uncaring world, carries the fight because . . . Why? Because someone has to.
Memorable scene: Sterling Hayden’s doomed alcoholic novelist Roger Wade ‘wades’ despairingly into the Pacific to end it all, as Marlowe, registering what’s happening too late, is powerless to stop him.

Out of the Past (1947)
You can’t take your eyes off Robert Mitchum throughout Jacques Tourneur’s movie, despite the beautifully-shot, evocative locations, both urban and (surprisingly for a noir) pastoral. The wistful feeling of the settings is matched by Mitchum’s portrayal of Jeff Bailey, a private eye trying to go straight but unable to because of his murky past. The profession of private detective here – as in so many other films – carries with it none of the romance we associate with a Philip Marlowe. As Bailey puts it in his opening lines, he does ‘shabby jobs for who’d ever hire me. It was the bottom of the barrel, and I scraped it, but I didn’t care. I had her.’
Memorable scene: one of the great femme fatale scenes in movie history, as Jane Greer’s Kathie Moffat looks on while Bailey and his former partner Fisher fight to the death in the claustrophobic surroundings of a rural cabin. As the camera shifts to her face we realise her expression conveys not fear but . . . unmistakable arousal.

Chinatown (1975)
A rare example of a great private eye movie written for screen rather than based on a literary original, Chinatown uses the qualities of cinema to elevate the popular thriller to the level of art. This ‘film blanc’ has everthing: absorbing plot (about the sins of the fathers, in every sense), convincing acting, lush cinematography and a haunting soundtrack. But what makes it unbeatably powerful is how plot and underlying themes lock together into an unforgettable conclusion: it’s not ignorance that hurts you, it’s what you know.
Memorable scene: another great private eye movie ending: a car horn sounds continuously as its driver collapses on the steering wheel after being shot. The sound seems to signify Jake Gittes’s recognition not only that he is completely powerless in the face of corrupt LA authorities, but that his own dark private history has repeated itself.

And three of the worst . . .

The Eye of the Beholder (1999)
Is it possible to make a film boring, when it’s about a seductive female serial killer and the voyeuristic detective who abandons his job because he has fallen for her? Yes: here’s the proof. Stephan Elliott’s adaptation of Marc Behm’s masterful 1980 novel is pedestrian and unwilling to fully inhabit the deranged desolation of the central character that drives both Behm’s novel and its original adaptation, Claude Miller’s Mortelle Randonée (1983). A miscast Ewan McGregor comes across as apologetic rather than unhinged.

The Lady in the Lake (1947)
You could see the appeal for Robert Montgomery, both director and star of this third Philip Marlowe movie. Why not try to create a literal cinematic equivalent of the first-person perspective of Chandler’s original fiction by confining the perspective to Marlowe’s? A drink is offered to the camera, then we see the detective’s hand putting it down; when Lavery punches him, we see the fist draw back and then the camera keels over and blacks out. But the effect is fatally stagey and unconvincing. Characters parade in front of the camera, eyeing the detective with exaggerated suspicion and intoning lines from the overly literary screenplay. And the attempt to make us hear Marlowe’s speech as if it’s our own voice fails too. One critic has remarked that when he tells Adrienne that her role in life is to take care of him, ‘it sounds as if he’s leaning out of a car window and ordering burgers and fries at a drive-through window’.

The Big Sleep (1975)
This film demonstrates why the conventions of the American private eye movie cannot be translated into an English setting without extreme care (or by giving them a comic makeover, as in Stephen Frears’s Gumshoe, 1971). Like The Lady in the Lake, it must have seemed like a good idea at the time, to build on the success of Dick Richards’ Farewell My Lovely (1975) in casting an ageing but stately Robert Mitchum as Philip Marlowe. Yet, as Mitchum wanders around a peculiarly 1970s British world of suburban semis, Fulham penthouses and mundane locations like ‘Hunt’s Garage’, he looks as if he’s having serious doubts.

Wednesday, 15 May 2013

A Space Oddity

Academics are wondering whether we are still postmodern, if the attitudes typical of the last few decades of the Twentieth Century still pertain in the early Twenty-first. Chris Hadfield's much-publicized return to Earth at the end of the International Space Station's 'Expedition 35' suggests that, in some places at least, they do.

Umberto Eco once characterized the 'postmodern attitude' as that of a man who wants to tell a woman that he loves her madly, but is all too aware 'that these words have already been written by Barbara Cartland' and is sure the woman will know this too. So his solution is to say to her: ‘as Barbara Cartland would put it, I love you madly’. Thus he simultaneously acknowledges his painful conviction that everything meaningful has been said or done by others before, how conscious we are of following pre-written 'cultural scripts' in our everyday lives... but also manages to communicate genuine emotion. Eco's analogy explained the fondness for the many examples of postmodern literature and film which chose to parody or copy previous works.

Hadfield's return to Earth neatly illustrated Eco's logic. His method was not unexpected for a man whose expedition has embraced media culture from he outset, demonstrating an ease with one's private life being lived out in public. An exchange on Twitter with fellow-Canadian William Shatner, for example, included the lines, 'Are you tweeting from space?' (Shatner), 'Yes, Standard Orbit, Captain. And we're detecting signs of life on the surface.' (Hadfield). His return involved him putting together a video which showed him performing David Bowie's 'Space Oddity' live in space. As well as acknowledging that space travel - and the momentous address to humankind that comes with it - had been done before, in reality (the original Moon Landing in 1969) and in fiction (Bowie's song, which is itself a parody of the Kubrick film, 2001), it also manages to communicate the genuine sense of achievement felt by Hadfield. Truer still to Eco's logic is that Bowie's song contains the line 'Tell my wife I love her very much, she knows' - a way of telling his own wife, even though Bowie's narrator has said this before, and that his wife surely knows this is the case, that he loves her very much.





Sunday, 28 October 2012

One Function of the Guardian/Observer for the Middle Classes (Neatly Encapsulated in the Title of a Single Article)

St Ives, Cornwall

'I feel defensive about my second home - but my guilt is largely unnecessary' (Ian Jack's column in The Guardian, Saturday 27 October 2012)

Monday, 22 October 2012

The Demon in the Machine: Paranormal Activity 4


The idea which runs through the Paranormal Activity series is that the visual technology which is so much a part of contemporary life might just capture something horrible, either by accident or design. In the original film (2009), a couple attempt to make sense of frightening paranormal disturbances which have been occurring in their new home at night – a light turning itself on and off in the hallway, a door opening by itself, loud thuds and crashes upstairs, etc. – by mounting a digital camera in their bedroom and recording while they sleep. This is followed by handheld cameras in Paranormal Activity 2 (2010), security cameras in Paranormal Activity 3 (2011), a prequel to the original, and now, in this fourth instalment, a series of networked laptops recording continually via webcam throughout the house.


Our handheld digital world has had a huge impact on cinema, and not just because the compact nature of digital cameras and smartphones – and their low prices – makes filming accessible to all. Where the mediatized global catastrophes of the Sixties were televisual (the assassinations of the Kennedy brothers, for example), in the twenty-first century, they have been digital. One effect of this is the way footage from 9/11 and the 2004 Tsunami taught film-makers how to really ‘do’ realistic disaster (e.g. in Cloverfield - see previous post). But what Paranormal Activity suggests is that there is something disturbing about the technology itself, something dangerous about our very compulsion to record every moment of our lives. What if the devices we deploy to protect ourselves should uncover, or even unleash, a submerged world we would be better off not knowing about?

Jane and Louise Wilson
 
In its heyday in the late Eighteenth Century, gothic fiction specialized in exotic, enclosed spaces, fitting locations for heightened  drama, such as the rooms in castles or monasteries. Now we are as likely to encounter the gothic in the ordinary spaces of our everyday world – not only the urban architectural spaces explored in the photography of Jane and Louise Wilson, but in everyday suburban kitchens, bedrooms and garages. ‘Suburban Gothic’ is a label coined by Bernice Murphy to refer to a major sub-genre within American gothic over the past few decades, which expresses the anxiety that beneath the surface of the most mundane of environments something extraordinary is lurking, something virulent or evil. The Paranormal Activity series is a recent example of a sequence of films that include Halloween (1981) and Disturbia (2005). The original film was set in a modest example of ‘tract’ housing, the sequels in more affluent villas. Each, though, is representative of ‘suburbia’.

From the outset, the plot has been the weakest link in the Paranormal Activity series, despite the creditable attempts to embellish it in the sequels. A demon has attached itself to one of two sisters, staying with her throughout her life as she moves from one suburban locale to another, making sure she and her offspring stay in his possession, eliminating anyone who gets in his way. But why this is the case, and even how it works, is less clear. In a way the story is rather un-gothic: demons are more monstrous but less uncanny than ghosts. But in the end this doesn’t matter. In Paranormal Activity 4 the simple plot – demon wants boy back – is just a pretext for the real business of the film: to show us how menacing the spaces of our ordinary lives are. The films gives us the Freudian uncanny in an especially direct sense: our homes are made unhomely by the act of scrutiny. It may be that the most problematic inconsistency of the story is the fact that a force formidable enough to drag adults through rooms, start cars, and send chandeliers crashing down on people, is apparently unable to turn off a laptop. Yet this demon has no interest in stopping the camera, for it is his biggest ally.

*Bernice Murphy, Suburban Gothic in American Popular Culture (Palgrave, 2009)



Monday, 6 August 2012

When I'm Cleaning... etc.

Ah, George Formby Jr. Classic, supremely talented yet unfairly neglected, etc.

I just about 'get' what the George Formby thing is all about. It's a Northern thing. It's a British thing. It's the kind of thing that makes movies like The Full Monty successful, the idea that 'we' can never be as good as them because we're not as privileged nor as confident in ourselves as they are... But we can try and have fun amidst all the hardship and a sense of community and identity will result. And along the way we can produce pretty good music, films, etc. In other words: we lowly, down-to-earth Brits are not the Americans. And we Northerners are not like you guys from the South...

Frank Skinner's documentary about Formby (August 5th, BBC Four) was dressed up as a reappraisal, designed to persuade us that Formby was deserving of a position in the Twentieth Century roster of brilliant, influential artists. A brilliant ukelele player, and a composer of neat, comic songs, yes. But influential? There's the problem. As Skinner's own performances of Formby songs showed, it seems impossible to 'do' a Formby song without 'doing Formby' (ie. singing in that silly voice). It becomes an impression, a karaoke performance. Given that the style of Formby's music probably descended from ragtime roots and is thus flexible enough to be reinterpreted, it seems surprising that no-one's tried to re-do Formby's songs in his or her own style. But then we come to another problem: those lyrics...

Monday, 30 July 2012

London 2012 - Opening Ceremony

Another example of the self-reflexivity of our heavily mediatized everyday reality: the opening ceremony to the Olympics consisted of Danny Boyle apparently extending the phantasmagoric drug-induced hallucination scenes from Trainspotting to put together a trippy dream of British history and contemporary British reality, which included such bizarre random moments as the Arctic Monkeys playing a version of their 2005 (yes, 2005!) hit 'I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor' and then a cover of one of John Lennon's most meaningless, yet unmistakably 1960s, songs 'Come Together'. Ok, this was perhaps an Olympic sentiment. But then Paul McCartney was wheeled out to sing 'Hey Jude'. Why? What has this man and this song got to do with the Olympics and/or Britain 2012? The only explanation is that he represents a kind of rock Royalty.


This then became news, with commentators discussing it on the news channels late into the nights. Screened on the BBC, then analysed on the BBC as if it just happended to be a randomly-generated news event, when actually the BBC were talking about themselves!

Wednesday, 4 April 2012

Contemporary British Cinema

There are three kinds of British movie: 1. the plucky disenfranchised group working together to achieve a momentary success (The Full Monty, Made in Dagenham, Calendar Girls), a film which promotes the 'having a go' side of British life, as people force themselves to do something badly for the greater good and to cheer themselves up; 2. the aspirational (London) movie, where a group of affluent metrosexuals impress the Americans (Love Actually, Four Weddings and a Funeral, etc.); 3. the gritty, dark, bleak portrait of the futility of working-class life (Fishtank, Red Road, Made in England). Only the third is any good. What does this say about Britain and its sense of itself?

Monday, 21 November 2011

Lilya 4-Ever

Possibly the bleakest film ever made, Lilya 4-ever (2002) tells the story of a 16-year-old girl living in extreme squalor in the former Soviet Union (Paldiski in Estonia, to be precise) who ends up becoming tricked by a 'boyfriend' into moving to Sweden in search of a better life only to find herself forced into a life of prostitution. Her departure leads her only friend, a boy named Volodya, to commit suicide. In the most touching scenes in the movie, he appears in her dreams as a guardian angel - the role she played for him but abandoned, just as her mother left her for the United States at the start of the story - and eventually advises her that her pimp has mistakenly left the door to the apartment unlocked, so she can escape. This she does... only to throw herself impulsively off a motorway bridge and die.


The key to the film comes at the end of the final credits in a dedication to 'children around the world exploited by the sex trade'. It signals that the film is bleak for a reason. Its naturalistic style is designed to shock viewers - especially Swedish ones - into recognising that all this actually happens, and that Sweden may be a wealthier and in some ways healthier nation than the states of the former Soviet Union, but has turned a blind eye to the practice of enforced child prostitution. The film is based on the real story of Danguole Rasalaite, a 16-year-old Lithuanian girl who died in similar circumstances in Malmo in 2000. But, at the same time, the film is art not documentary. Maybe I spent too long reading Iris Murdoch's aesthetic theory but a film like this can't help but make me wonder whether art has a duty to provide some kind of redemption to its viewers. The only glimpse into redemption here is the secure but limited afterlife inhabited by Volodya. But his suicide is something he regrets.


Still, seeking relief after the final credits, I turned over to BBC4 and saw an extraordinarily cynical piece of historical revisionism which made Lilya 4-ever's determination to be accurate all the more laudable. 'Taking Control' was a documentary about Janet Jackson, which used the manipulative 'talking heads' format (show someone a clip, ask them to describe it, then edit to make it look as if the topic was so memorable it's impact is still fresh in the interviewee's mind) to try to convince us that she was a hugely influential R&B artist whose 1980s output changed the face of music history. I remember the 1980s, Janet, I was there... I'm not having that. Where's the nearest motorway bridge?

Saturday, 12 November 2011

The X Factor and the H Factor

TV is a naturally self-reflexive medium and the TV genre which demonstrates this most clearly is the reality game show. Rising above the myriad sentimental mini-stories which makes up the background of its contestants, the real story of each X Factor series is television's power to transform the lives of ordinary people. The contestants are invited into the televisual universe with the promise that they'll never have to go back to their own, non-tube world. This year's X Factor represents the summit of its particular way of executing this promise, due to a perfect blend of hype, suspense, and reasonable singers. Most of all, though, it is being achieved through the X Factor's mastery of the key principle of reality TV shows: transformation.

But here we can see that the X Factor has now gorged on itself until bloated with its own excessive content. Here are the symptoms:

1. Two judges (Tulisa and Kelly Rowlad) who possess minimal credibility - at least when it comes to the business at which they're professing to excel: scouting and producing talent. Discovering talent and transforming the artists into what they wanted is the background of Simon Cowell and Louis Walsh, and ensures they each possess authority. But Tulisa and Kelly are just singers - for all their 'urban' credentials. (And Tulisa protests her urban credentials so much it comes to seem suspicious. I suspect stage school...)

2. No alternative to Walsh's almost uniform praise. This series is giving us the spectacle of one average karaoke performance after another being greeted with a chorus of 'you have a great voice'. Great? Shouldn't that word be saved for something genuinely special?

3. The dismembering and re-assembling of bands by the judges. A feature of this series is under-qualified judges (see point 1) hubristically creating bands, mixing up members of existing bands (which themselves seem thrown together in the first place). This should really be a new kind of XFactor-type show, in which individual singers are slotted into bands designed and managed by the judges and left to fight it out on stage, a kind of musical Bamzooki. Maybe it could be called...Popstars?

Perhaps the most telling of all the symptoms of decadance - more than the vast number of dancers upstaging every act in dazzling displays, more than the hubristic appearance of contestants appearing as 'stars' in an M&S Christmas ad - is Frankie Cocozza's accelerated entire rock n' roll-biography-in-6-weeks demise. Of course this could have happened any year, but somehow it seems as if it could only happen this year, the year the X Factor - or H for hubris Factor - ate itself.

Monday, 24 October 2011

Signed by Katie Price


Meanwhile, back at Reality Talent Show Central... Katie Price has launched her own version of the X Factor, but with a twist unprecedented in world of reality talent shows. This time Katie and her team of judges are looking for... another Katie!

The contestants go through what is by now a highly familiar sequence. The ‘live’ auditions (in front of the audience, Katie, and an unconvincingly stern couple of fellow judges who resemble bullied men each tentatively trying to inhabit the persona of an alpha male) are followed by the ‘judges' house’ section (only it’s not really Katie’s house, but a country pile which stokes the aspirational hysteria of the contestants still further), then the 'final twelve' stage (only it’s thirteen, for some reason... and then twelve again as one gets sent home early because he backed two horses on the reality talent show merry-go-round and goes off to appear on Big Brother) as a handful of lucky contestants get to move into a luxury house together to go through an increasingly exacting series of tasks.
Add caption
There are hysterical celebrations at the luxury surroundings, tears as the contestants vie with each other for Katie's affection, and lectures or hugs from the hostess as she awkwardly tries to display her 'people-skills' (actually she seems uncomfortable, even a touch timid, whenever she has to address the contestants).



As familiar as all these rituals are, however, one question lingers over proceedings. What, exactly, are the contestants auditioning for? 

Clearly the judges are looking for someone - either male or female - blessed with all of Katie's attributes: good-looking (especially if it's the kind of not-so-obvious good looks which mean one can undergo the transformation from 'duck to swan', to use Katie's favourite metaphor), business-savvy, determined, professional. But what exactly is the chosen one going to do, once 'signed by Katie Price'? We know from the business meetings we see between Katie and her management team that the winner will have their own website, a presence on twitter, and splashes in major media outlets. Yet can they be anything other than glamour models? The tasks in the series - at which point it becomes more like The Apprentice than the X Factor - would have us think they can. After all, they have been working together to achieve complex business goals such as, er, making homemade t-shirts. But surely it's impossible to repeat Katie Price's trick of being famous for being famous without doing so through one's own efforts and not those of a management team, no matter how media-savvy they are. Katie's own narcissistic drive has got her where she is. Displacing that drive onto a protege surely cannot work.


Writing about 'Loft Story', a French version of Big Brother, Jean Baudrillard outlined the principle of 'radical democracy' upon which he thought reality TV is founded. Democracy as we used to understand it was based on an 'order of merit, and on an equivalence between merit and recognition'. The more you deserved it, the more recognition you received. But in the world of Big Brother, 'there's no equivalence between merit and glory'. Contestants receive 'maximum exultation for minimum qualification'. Minimal qualifications are apparently crucial to Signed by Katie Price. One of them, Nathan, says, 'I just want to be known, big time'. Another, Susie, describes herself without a trace of irony as 'a blank canvas'. Jemma tells us 'I just want to show Katie what I can do', and then we see her climbing awkwardly onto a horse for a photoshoot and Katie telling her 'I want you like that... sort of, leaning'. The series is proof that what really matters in the reality talent show is not the content but the rituals, the structure, the very televisual mechanism itself. What drives it are: 1. the relentless desire of contestants to be known, big time (rather than to show off a particular talent); 2. the endless process of judging and elimination, 3. the mechanics of transformation, as a nobody becomes a somebody, a duck becomes a swan, all through the magical power of television. The contestants - and the judges, as X Factor proves - are all ultimately dispensible, all interchangeable, just so long as the machine clanks on. This is why Signed by Katie Price, though utterly execrable, nevertheless represents the genre at its purest.

Jeff Koons, Hook (2003)
And of course this particular show is not really about producing a Katie clone, or a credible replacement for her in some strand of her publicity empire. The title says it all: it's the signature that's important. What matters is being signed by Katie Price, just as the signature of the artist confers value upon an artwork - and indeed just as she herself sold millions of copies of ghostwritten novels (Angel and Crystal) by branding them with her name. This real aim of the show is alluded to subtly throughout. As the brief profiles are put on screen to enable viewers to disintinguish between the final twelve contestants, it is noticeable how many times, alongside banal, 'individualizing' facts such as 'hates spiders', 'is a mummy's boy', etc. contestants claim to 'fancy Katie Price', or to have 'a shelf full of Katie Price products' at home. The show is really a glorified fanclub outing, a meet your heroine day. One lucky fan, though, will become a walking postmodern work of art - signed by Katie Price.

Sunday, 16 October 2011

The Banality of Magic: The Tooth Fairy

Before watching this, I couldn't help envisaging a children's film starring the terrifying serial killer in Red Dragon. And sure enough, the sinister implications of a job which involves intruding into people's homes at night and visiting their children as they lie alone in their beds is something the film can never quite conquer, despite the acquiesence of the child characters. It's made worse by the outfit that its hero settles on to play the Tooth Fairy - a combination of Disney fairy and ice hockey uniform, one of the looks favoured by scary characters in slasher movies, not to mention his charming habit of spraying an 'amnesiac-spray', which seems like CS gas, into people's faces to stop them questioning him. What a mischievous man!


But this is not the most problematic contradiction in the movie. Almost the last line in the movie is when the elf-like creature played by Billy Crystal yells 'I love my job!' as he sits on a goal-bound ice-hockey puck. It's amazing how important work is to Hollywood kids movies. The Tooth Fairy is another example (see Santa Claus or Monsters Inc.) of Hollywood's determination to show us that magic is a particular kind of work. It's almost impossible to immerse yourself in the movie without grappling with the obvious irony upon which it rests. In a world in which 'children just don't believe anymore', the movie sets out to demonstrate that magic really happens, and anyone can 'believe'. It does this by propelling its cynical, charmless hero, Derek Thompson (played quite appropriately, if not deliberately, without an iota of charm by Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson) into the world of the tooth fairy. Having been on the point of telling his girlfriend's six-year-old daughter that the tooth fairy does not exist (to get himself off the hook from stealing her tooth money) Derek is suddenly sentenced to a week's community service where he has to become a tooth fairy. And, surprise surprise, what does Fairyland look like but a large US corporation in which hierarchies are rigidly sustained, employees are cynical yet continue to do their jobs, and the whole operation depends upon a series of tried-and-tested processes being applied smoothly and without question. It's a kind of strange 'reverse-Marxism': the Hollywood machine seeks to uphold the values of magic by demystifying them, revealing that the escapist fantasy-world which provides the antidote to the dreary world of reality (signified here by Derek's declining career as a once-lauded ice hockey pro) in fact runs on precisely the same principles. Magic, in other words, needs to be run like a large business. More than this, to really change things does not require magic so much as hard work, energy and focus: this is how Derek finally rescues himself from a boorish hell, by working damn hard.

Monday, 21 March 2011

Berkeley Hippies

Berkeley, California: beautiful university, strange city. 'Come for the culture, but stay for the food', said the tourist slogan. But other than the University (very cultured, no doubt about it) it was difficult to see what other culture this might to have referred to, apart from its subculture... And I found this a combination of the disturbing and the commodified.

The most striking thing about non-university Berkeley is its culture of Hippiedom. Hippies live on the streets there, partying like it was 1969. Except of course we're long after 1969... So it made me wonder: is it possible to be a 'proper' hippy post-Manson? The hippies I encountered, predominantly men in their fifties sporting frizzy goatees and coloured round shades, and producing a half-hearted street-theatre (sitting on the pavement, walking on tightropes, selling clothes and 2nd-hand books, etc.), seemed uniformly menacing.

But it also reminded me that postmodernism, contrary to much of the theory, can be a very unself-conscious practice rather anything deliberately self-reflexive. You can 'be' someone by following a cultural script. But the script is complex and many-faceted, a veritable wiki-text of meanings and values. Manson turned the values of the 60s inside-out, in a process we could term (after Baudrillard) 'reversibility'. To be a hippy, all you have to do is buy the tie-dyed clothes and display the anti-authoritarian slogans. But this look is saturated not just with connotations of peace and love, but with Manson and Altamont.

Friday, 18 February 2011

For All You Champions

If it were possible to stick a microphone in front of the Freudian ego and record its stream of consciousness directly, the chances are it would sound like Chipmunk's current single (featuring Chris Brown), 'Champion'. The Ego, as emphasized by Lacan, is an essentially paranoid entity which sustains one's imaginary sense of self by relentlessly promoting an illusion about how important, valuable, beautiful, etc. one is, while constantly portraying others as hostile threats to this self. This is the world we enter on listening to 'Champion'. People are constantly holding Chris Brown back (and, I suppose, 'Chipmunk', too), knocking him off his pedestal, telling him he couldn't be famous. But he retorts, stirringly

I'm always pushing myself to the limit
making sure I stay ahead....
Some people have to learn
some people wait their turn
some people but not me
I was born a champion

Such egomania is common in contemporary 'R&B' (as it's misleadingly called). R. Kelly, for example, sings in 'The World's Greatest':

If anybody asks you who I am
Just stand up tall
Look 'em in the face and say
I'm that star up in the sky
I'm that mountain peak up high
Hey, I made it
I'm the world's greatest

How close this posturing comes to desperation, however, is clear from Bonnie 'Prince' Billy's ironic but beautiful version, from his 2007 EP 'Ask Forgiveness', where his sweet, tentative, cracked delivery makes the words sound like the heartbreaking incantation of a damaged man. That's the thing about the ego: it deliberately misrepresents the outside world to protect the self. But Chris Brown's world is also that of so much of our culture: its character is that of the narcissistic personality, struggling to recognise true otherness. The fact that 'now my dream and reality is simultaneous', as Brown states, is not a positive outcome but a danger.

It may be stirring to misrecognise yourself in the lines 'it’s only you believing in you' or 'go get it in sonny!' which you hear in the background as you work the cross-trainer in the gym... But what happens when reality does intrude, and one's self-belief and determination lead nowhere? This is where we open the door to another space, next to the one labelled 'Champions' - the world of 'Nobodies Who Want to Be Somebodies' as featured in films like Taxi Driver or The Assassination of Richard Nixon. 'Here is a man who would not take it anymore...'

Tuesday, 15 February 2011

Catfish

I've rarely found a film so gripping, absorbing, disturbing as Catfish. It's a masterpiece, a film entirely representative of its age - whatever you might think of how authentic it is. Forum-posters and bloggers have been preoccupied by the question of whether the film is a real or a fake documentary (e.g. see http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1584016/board/nest/171604160). I'm a little unmoved by accusations of fakery in relation to fiction and film, for standard 'postmodern' reasons... If this is a fake, it only reveals how all representation of reality are faked, in so far as what they depict is edited, framed, constructed, etc.

Nevertheless there is something funny about the opening of Catfish, for it seems we're suddenly plunged into a story which requires some crucial scene-setting but which is not forthcoming. It looks as if the protagonist, Nev, has started to received paintings of his photos, apparently done by an 8-year-old girl, out of the blue, and is so intrigued he follows them up. Yet my suspicion is that the seduction has in fact worked the other way around: the paintings or at least further contact with their producer were somehow invited by the film-makers. Rather than Nev (pronounced Neev or perhaps 'naive') and co being sucked in to Angela's scheme, her fantasies have made her vulnerable to theirs...

But no matter how conscious or not any of the participants were of their role in the movie, I think what makes it so powerful is its structure. The viewer is carefully presented with the kind of virtual, layered, mediated world typical of twenty-first century life, a world of google maps, youtube, and facebook, only to be suddenly confronted, without warning, with a shocking aspect of reality. This is the world of the two severely disabled brothers whom Angela cares for. Even if she or her husband Vince (who delivers a suspiciously powerful and articulate monologue at the end of the movie, explaining its title), are somehow in on the scam, the life we're given a glimpse into is starkly, uncontestably real: this, we recognise painfully, is what looking after two helpless, unfortunate beings would be like. This is the unexpected triumph of the movie: never mind its self-reflexive commentary on self-presentation in the digital age, nestling within is an unfliching, unglamourised, picture of the kind of quotidian American life which is practically invisible across cultural forms: the isolated drudgery of ordinary, blue-collar American life, a world away from the affluent, loft-dwelling universe inhabited by Nev. And the fact that the movie shows us this is perhaps the single most powerful counter to the accusations that the whole thing is staged by clever, exploitative film-makers.

Friday, 4 February 2011

Bad Boys

Long after its original release I still hear Alexandra Burke emoting her line about how 'the bad boys are always catching my eye'. I wonder what 'bad boys' she has in mind. Shoplifters? Cheats? Murderers? Serial killers? No doubt they catch her eye because they know they've found a potential victim. Or maybe these bad boys are just blokes who leave her to do all the dishes and their washing without so much as a thank you?


The song is still around because it taps into a fantasy subscribed to by many women: The Bad Boy, a man who will treat you mean to keep you keen. This fantasy was the subject of an IT Crowd episode, where Roy sets out to prove that women choose 'bastards' by writing an insulting lonely hearts ad and seeing how many replies he gets. He is almost instantly successful. Yet the show's idiot-savant Moss grasps the spirit of the game even better than he does, writing 'I will murder you'. As a self-styled 'good boy' (just as much of a fantasy of course) I've always loved this episode. It's a kind of strike back at the Bad Boys... Can't imagine them watching the IT Crowd, though.

Wednesday, 2 February 2011

Barney's Version

Barney's Version resembles Sideways, one of my favourite movies of the last decade or so. Where at the heart of that film was the touching friendship between two men, here we have a sweetly loving relationship between father (Dustin Hoffman) and son (Paul Giamatti). This is the antidote to the Hollywood compulsion to portray Oedipal father-son 'tension then resolution' (a recurring sympton most evident in the remade Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, ie the one where Johnny Depp plays Michael Jackson playing Gene Wilder playing Willy Wonka... which makes only one significant addition to Roald Dahl's plot: the insertion of a 'wild psychoanalytic' explanation of just why Wonka is so wonky... it's because of the lack of approval from his mean dentist-father, of course!). In Barney's Version we have a father who loves his son unconditionally and it's refreshing to see.

The rest of the film is not in such rude health, however, but suffers from memory lapses and identity-crises. Of course it's a film about memory lapses and identity-crises... but it starts out as a Sideways-style portrait of an endearingly-dysfunctional male then becomes a murder-mystery and then finally a brooding study of Alzheimer's. Neither of these three stories is finished, just as none of Barney's women are believable (why is he so obsessed by the cold, detached Rosamund Pike character?). Ah, but isn't this how the film cleverly comments on the mystery of narrative construction? I'm not convinced. The movie suffers from having no way to replicate effectively the self-reflexivity of Mordecai Richler's original novel, which includes footnotes inserted by Barney's son to cover gaps in his memory and thus comments on the reliability of memory and narrative. In the end, the film is like a biopic of a famous person that we ourselves mysteriously can't recall. Without the context of a real life viewers are familiar with through the media - despite the brilliant acting of Giamatti - we're unable to understand just why the story of this man should be so important to tell.

Tuesday, 26 October 2010

Still Acting Paranormally

The film critic Vivian Sobchack once argued* that in sci-fi films like Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956) viewers are forced into an unusually active role by the sheer 'minimal activity' of what we see on screen. This seduces us into 'an attentive paranoia which makes us lean forward to scan what seem like the most intentionally and deceitfully flat images for signs of aberrant alien behaviour from the most improbable of suspects'. They thus bear out Lawrence Alloway's view that suspense is nothing happening. The rationale behind both Paranormal Activity movies raise this attentive paranoia up a notch by exploiting the familiar eerie, empty, luminous world of the security camera. As we sit in the cinema we feverishly scan every nook and corner of the rooms depicted on the screen waiting for an intrusion. It's a film, in fact, which counters the conventional logic of cinema in these times of supersize TVs. Paranormal Activity is really 'made for the small-screen'.


Paranormal Activity 2, somewhat improbably, manages to repeat the same trick as the original, largely by increasing the dimensions of the scrutinized space, the number of rooms, mirrors and doors, the number of characters (including the most vulnerable person of all, an infant), and adding more adept special effects and more chilling set-pieces. This time, too, I found the 'demon' myth more persuasive. In the first movie, the uncanniness of the sudden intrusions into the tableaux of domestic ordinariness (the dramatic making-unfamiliar of the familiar, homely space) was diluted by the idea that the demon, a less uncanny horror figure than ghost or poltergeist, was living in the loft like a difficult lodger, burning photos and dragging bits and pieces upstairs. PA2 provides a more intriguing back-story, to the effect that Katie and her sister's grandmother must have made a deal with the demon in return for giving him (it?) the first-born male child from her family line. It makes Katie a much more sinister figure - and increases the uncanny feel of the demonic possession scenes involving both sisters.

The film also does an admirable job of remaining compatible with the narrative of the original film - and expanding it. PA2 is not just a sequel but a kind of prequel and 'simul-quel' too. Yet the three-weeks gap following the transfer of demonic energy from one sister to another makes me wonder even more about the demon. It asks us to imagine that a creature which has largely confined itself to living in an untidy cellar, periodically making clumsy trips upstairs to rattle pans, turn off lights and remove the pool cleaner from the pool, is capable of negotiating the busy highways from one part of California to the other in order to hatch a plot whereby he will inhabit one sister, kill her boyfriend, return to the original house, kill the other sister and her husband and then take an infant which he surely could have simply kidnapped without fuss in the first place. It is not the most efficient campaign. This demon clearly has a taste for complexity - or rather a strong aesthetic sensibility. What is curious throughout the films is not his terrifying power so much as his restraint. Why, when he is capable of subduing an Alsation in an instant or dragging an adult downstairs and possessing her within minutes, is he apparently unable to remove an unsuspecting child from his cot? Why, for that matter, is a creature who is able to manipulate teenagers into spelling out 'Hunter' on a ouija board seemingly unable to scratch out something legible on the cellar door? The only conclusion is that the demon is not just the reason for the terrible narrative but its auteur as well. He knows that Alloway is wrong. Suspense is not 'nothing happening' but lots of little things escalating over time into bigger things.

The question the film leaves us with is how the third instalment - if there is one - will unfold. My money's on a representation of a different kind of domestic normality, where the teenager Ali tracks down the Demon, Katie and Hunter to an untidy apartment somewhere else in California, where they live in dysfunctional splendour, trying to manage his demonic outbursts, and watching reruns of Invasion of the Body Snatchers.


*in Screening Space: The American Science Fiction Film (1997)

Thursday, 14 October 2010

The Apprentice

Joy Stefanicki: fired, 13th October 2010
I spend half of each episode of The Apprentice constantly on the point of switching over. I find the abrasive stupidity of the contestants almost unbearable. These are not the sort of people I want to spend any time with - even if they are on the other side of the screen. Here we have the normalized 'narcissistic personality disorder' of the Big Brother generation fused with the normative ideology of business: 'I say exactly what I think, I get exactly what I want, I will win at all costs...'. The beauty of Big Brother, though, is that the format itself - especially the extreme length of the time most contestants must spend in the house - means that this ego-shell is peeled away bit by bit until it's patently obvious that the proclamations of the contestants is all bluster.

A similar argument is often used about the moral punishment dealt out on The Apprentice. The beauty of this show, the argument goes, is that we can rejoice in seeing the most obnoxious people flayed by Sir Alan, scourge of the vain and stupid, in the boardroom at the end. Last night's episode, for example, revealed Joanna as mouthy and unnecessarily combative in the tasks and then forced to acknowledge her 'aggressive' nature by Sir Alan. Strangely, though, neither she nor her inept team-leader, Laura (who boasted at the start she could deal with any kind of personality only to demonstrate she could deal successfully with no-one) was fired. No, it was their fellow team-member Joy - ironically-named yet essentially well-meaning. Why? Because she was deemed to have shown Sir Alan 'nothing' in two weeks. And this, ultimately, is why I hate The Apprentice: the narcissistic aggressivity of the candidates is validated by Sugar's own business ethic. The lesson of each episode is: you have to show yourself as mouthy, aggressive, contemptuous towards others, determined to win at all costs... but you just have to do it in the right way.

Friday, 11 June 2010

A Lethal Weapon

On the day after Derrick Bird shot dead 12 people in Cumbria BBC Radio 4 broadcast a play entitled Six Impossible Things. Based on the true story of a murderer, it contained the line 'I'll put a bullet in your brain'. 66 complaints were made to the network, which quickly apologised and declared it had been wrong to broadcast the play. Why did this upset people? Who were they? Could they be protesting about anything more than ironic coincidence?

This seems part of the disturbing willingness to be part of a 'community of grief' which has marked British society since the death of Diana. People seem to need to think of themselves as 'victims' of tragic events, imagining that it's just too painful in their grief-stricken state to be confronted with images of any sort of violence. I vividly remember that a day or so after Diana's death the scheduled movie, Lethal Weapon III, was replaced by the sentimental (and wonderful) film, Field of Dreams, as if watching Mel Gibson's wild staring eyes as he brandished the eponymous firearm was just too upsetting for those in a fragile state after the tragedy. Of course this sentimentality is all media-led, as the duty of the news networks and newspapers is seemingly to create a community united in outrage and grief. The BBC is the prime offender here, so at least there is another irony: that its drama wing has to play by the strange rules it enforces elsewhere.

Tuesday, 1 June 2010

Because You Were Home: The Strangers



The Strangers is a film utterly without redemption - along the lines of ‘torture porn’ movies such as the Saw series and Wolf Creek. Having endured the motiveless terrorizing and torture of a couple who just happen to be ‘home’ when a group of random attackers choose to call, we are left with no hope, not even a deeper ‘point’. The opening of the film refers to some real event which ‘inspires’ the movie, though the makers appear to be unaware what this actually was or unwilling to reveal it. More likely, they don’t care. 

The opening is genuinely scary, especially when the girl knocks at the door at 4 in the morning asking for ‘Tamar’ and, when told she’s not there, says plaintively ‘Are you sure?'. When we see one of the attackers suddenly inside the house, on the margins of the frame, while the central Liv Tyler character remains oblivious, it's absolutely terrifying. But from then on the movie has nowhere to go. It seems unsure and indifferent to what the point of all this is, other than – to go by the word of the director on the accompanying DVD Extras – to provide some innovative kind of movie horror experience. But this ambition extends beyond little other than technical innovations such as constructing the house in a vast studio so that the echoes are as loud and spooky as possible.

No, if there is a point it is simply that one’s home can be easily invaded. It thus reminds me of David Hare’s comment that the message underpinning Patricia Highsmith’s fiction is that ‘once you set your mind to it, any one human being can destroy any other’. In The Strangers, when asked by the Liv Tyler character why they do this, the masked intruders reply: ‘Because you were home’. This seems to refer to the victims just happening to be in while the killers were on their random spree. But it also conveys a deeper logic, that being ‘home’, counter to all the conventional connotations of safety and security, is where you are at your most vulnerable. This message is in keeping with the general paranoid tenor of 21st century America. But it's actually something that horror films have taught us more implicitly for decades. Think of the common post-horror-film experience of having your own house transformed suddenly into a location for potential evil as you eye dark spaces nervously and rush past empty rooms on the way to the safety of bed. It's the home that is made strange.